Skip to content

Two Conflicting Accounts of the Arrest

The exact circumstances surrounding the arrest of Liam and his father remain the subject of heated debate, with radically conflicting accounts from authorities and witnesses. ICE claims that the operation targeted the father, that Liam was with him in a vehicle when agents approached, and that the father attempted to flee on foot, abandoning his child in the vehicle in the middle of winter. Marcos Charles, ICE’s acting director of removal operations, stated that agents had “taken care of” Liam, taken him to a drive-through restaurant, and made multiple attempts to return the child to his family, but that the people inside the house had refused to take the child or open the door.

However, witnesses and family members tell a very different story. Sergio Amezcua, a pastor who spoke with Liam’s mother, said she was “terrified” during the incident and that ICE agents were trying to use the baby to lure her out of her home. “The ICE agents were trying to use the baby to get her to come out of her house, but the neighbors intervened. The neighbors advised her not to do it,” Amezcua explained, noting that the mother—who is pregnant and also has a teenage son—feared she would be detained if she opened the door. Mary Granlund, president of the Columbia Heights Public Schools board of education, who was at the scene, described a chaotic scene with witnesses shouting at the agents, “What are you doing? Don’t take the child!” and offering to look after the child—to no avail.

What outrages me most about this story is ICE’s manipulation of the facts. They want us to believe that the father abandoned his child, that the mother refused to take care of her son. But that’s not what the witnesses saw. What they saw was a family terrorized by armed, masked agents. What they saw was a pregnant mother trembling with fear. What they saw was a five-year-old child being used as leverage to force his mother out. ICE is trying to absolve itself of blame by portraying itself as the saviors, the ones who “took care” of the child. It’s obscene. It’s an abuse of language and power. You cannot kidnap a child and claim to have taken care of him. You cannot sow terror in a family and present yourselves as good Samaritans.

The Legal Status of the Family in Question

One of the most contentious issues concerns the legal status of Liam and his father. Marc Prokosch, the family’s attorney, asserts that Liam and his family are from Ecuador and presented themselves to border agents in Texas in December 2024 to seek asylum. “They are not illegal aliens,” Prokosch insisted. “They were following all established protocols, pursuing their asylum claim, appearing at their court hearings, and posed no security risk or flight risk—and should never have been detained.” According to Prokosch, Liam’s father has no criminal record in Minnesota or in Ecuador, his country of origin.

However, the Department of Homeland Security described Liam’s father as an “illegal alien” who was the target of the operation and disputed that the father had entered the United States legally. DHS spokesperson Tricia McLaughlin stated that “the law requires that those who are in the country illegally be detained pending deportation.” DHS records do not suggest that the father has a criminal record, according to a source familiar with the case. Furthermore, CBS News reviewed Department of Justice records and confirmed that Liam and his father have pending cases in immigration court listed as “pending, with no removal order, meaning that an immigration judge has yet to review Liam’s and his father’s applications before any attempt at removal.

ICE denies using Liam as bait

In response to allegations that agents used Liam as bait, ICE has strongly denied these accusations. In a message posted on Twitter, the agency stated: “My team and I have never used a child as bait.” Marcos Charles, ICE’s acting director of removal operations, added: “My officers did everything they could to reunite him with his family.” The agency claims that agents spent 90 minutes trying to hand Liam over to his mother or another responsible adult in the home, to no avail.

However, officials at the Columbia Heights Public School District stand by their account of events. In a statement, the school district said that “agents walked him to the door and told him to knock so they could assess whether anyone else was home.” The school district also revealed that Liam is the fourth student in its district to be taken by ICE in the last two weeks alone, underscoring the scale of the federal operation in the area. This contradiction between the school’s allegations and ICE’s denials is fueling suspicion and anger within the community.

Sources

Primary Sources

In These Times – “ICE Is Made Up of a Bunch of Cowards” by Margaret Vail Palmquist – January 23, 2026

CNN – “A preschooler was taken away by ICE, but officials say they had no choice. Here’s what we know” by Holly Yan and Priscilla Alvarez – January 23, 2026

CBS News – “5-year-old taken into custody by ICE has active immigration case, preventing deportation for now” by Camilo Montoya-Galvez – January 23, 2026

PBS NewsHour – “Migrant families allege children held by ICE face unsafe and unsanitary conditions” – January 20, 2026

In These Times – “‘Everybody Showed Up’: Stunning Crowds at Minnesota Day of Strike and Shutdown Against ICE” by Sarah Lazare – January 23, 2026

Secondary Sources

ABC News – “5-Year-Old Asylum Seeker Detained as ICE Expands Enforcement” – January 22, 2026

Minnesota Public Radio – “ICE detains 5-year-old Minnesota boy; school leader says agents used him as bait” – January 21, 2026

People.com – “ICE Detains 5-Year-Old Boy Returning Home from Preschool” – January 21, 2026

BBC – “ICE detains five-year-old and father in Minnesota, lawyer says” – January 23, 2026

El País – “Detention of five-year-old child by ICE adds fuel to the fire in the streets of Minneapolis” – January 23, 2026

This content was created with the help of AI.

facebook icon twitter icon linkedin icon
Copied!

Commentaires

0 0 votes
Article Rating
Subscribe
Notify of
guest
0 Comments
Newest
Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
More Content